A four time All-TIAA performer at slotback and punt returner, McCormick was a 1st Team All-American selection at HSU in 1993 and 1994. In 1993 he was the nationis eighth-leading punt returner, averaging 11.5 yards per return. His 90 yard punt return for TD in a 1992 game at Millsaps College tied a school record. For his career Collin had 23 touchdowns and 3,035 receiving yards, 4,532 career all-purpose yards, single game punt return yards (142 vs. Austin College in 1991), and 307 career receptions. He holds the record for most catches in a game (22) in a playoff loss to Lambuth (TN). In that game McCormick was named USA Player of the Week, and he set a single game scoring record with 26 points.