In nine seasons at HSU, Goodenough coached three All-Americans, 34 All Conference Selections and 46 Academic All-Conference selections. She left HSU as the leader in coaching wins, reaching 150 victories in less than 200 games. The Cowgirls captured seven conference championships and made five consecutive NCAA post-season appearances while Goodenough posted a 188-54 career record. Goodenough became head coach at Oklahoma State University in 2002 where she recruited and coached the Big 12 Newcomer of the Year. Under Goodenough, the Cowgirls had five of the largest home crowds in OSU history, including the largest crowd to ever watch a women’s game. Goodenough became the head coach at Charleston Southern University in 2006, and the team won the Big South Sportsmanship Award in her first year.